5. Concept Evaluation And Product Architecture - B-Division-2021-2022-Odd/Repo-01 GitHub Wiki
ASSIGNING WEIGHTS TO THE OBJECTIVES
OBJECTIVE | WEIGHTS |
---|---|
Public Use | 5 |
Different Compartments | 9 |
Aesthetic | 2 |
Fully Automated | 7 |
PUGH CHART
Design Objectives | Weights | Design 1 | Design 2 | Design 3 | Design4 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Public Use | 5 | ++ | ++ | Datum | + |
Different Compartments | 9 | + | ++ | Datum | ++ |
Aesthetic | 2 | + | + | Datum | + |
Fully Automated | 7 | ++ | ++ | Datum | ++ |
Score(+) | 46 | 35 | 44 | 0 | 39 |
Score(-) | - | - | - | - | - |
Total | 46 | 35 | 44 | 0 | 39 |
5.1 JUSTIFICATION FOR SCORES GIVEN
Design No | Objective | Score Allocated | Justification for the score |
---|---|---|---|
1 | Public Use | 10 | Compact |
Different Compartments | 9 | Small Compartments | |
Aesthetic | 2 | Not good looking | |
Fully Automated | 14 | Automatic | |
2 | Public Use | 10 | Compact and Portable |
Different Compartments | 18 | Well defined compartments | |
Aesthetic | 2 | Looks good compared to datum | |
Fully Automated | 14 | Compeletely Automatic | |
3 | Public Use | Datum | |
Different Compartments | Datum | ||
Aesthetic | Datum | ||
Fully Automated | Datum | ||
4 | Public Use | 5 | Bigger in Size |
Different Compartments | 18 | Well Defined Compartments | |
Aesthetic | 2 | Looks good when compared to datum | |
Fully Automated | 14 | Completely Automatic |
5.2 Finalized Concept
5.3 SUBSYSTEM LIST
SL.NO | SUBSYSTEM LIST |
---|---|
1 | Waste Disposing Unit |
2 | Display Unit |
3 | Sanitizer Unit |
5.4 INTERACTION DETAILS
Waste Disposing Unit | Display Unit | Sanitizer Unit |
---|---|---|
Spatial interaction | YES | NO |
Data | YES | NO |
Material | NO | NO |
Display Unit | Waste Disposing Unit | Sanitizer Unit |
---|---|---|
Spatial interaction | YES | NO |
Data | NO | NO |
Material | NO | NO |
Sanitizer Unit | Waste Disposing Unit | Display Unit |
---|---|---|
Spatial intrection | NO | NO |
Data | NO | NO |
Material | NO | NO |