5. Concept Evaluation And Product Architecture - B-Division-2021-2022-Odd/Repo-01 GitHub Wiki

ASSIGNING WEIGHTS TO THE OBJECTIVES

OBJECTIVE WEIGHTS
Public Use 5
Different Compartments 9
Aesthetic 2
Fully Automated 7

PUGH CHART

Design Objectives Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design4
Public Use 5 ++ ++ Datum +
Different Compartments 9 + ++ Datum ++
Aesthetic 2 + + Datum +
Fully Automated 7 ++ ++ Datum ++
Score(+) 46 35 44 0 39
Score(-) - - - - -
Total 46 35 44 0 39

5.1 JUSTIFICATION FOR SCORES GIVEN

Design No Objective Score Allocated Justification for the score
1 Public Use 10 Compact
Different Compartments 9 Small Compartments
Aesthetic 2 Not good looking
Fully Automated 14 Automatic
2 Public Use 10 Compact and Portable
Different Compartments 18 Well defined compartments
Aesthetic 2 Looks good compared to datum
Fully Automated 14 Compeletely Automatic
3 Public Use Datum
Different Compartments Datum
Aesthetic Datum
Fully Automated Datum
4 Public Use 5 Bigger in Size
Different Compartments 18 Well Defined Compartments
Aesthetic 2 Looks good when compared to datum
Fully Automated 14 Completely Automatic

5.2 Finalized Concept

5.3 SUBSYSTEM LIST

SL.NO SUBSYSTEM LIST
1 Waste Disposing Unit
2 Display Unit
3 Sanitizer Unit

5.4 INTERACTION DETAILS

Waste Disposing Unit Display Unit Sanitizer Unit
Spatial interaction YES NO
Data YES NO
Material NO NO
Display Unit Waste Disposing Unit Sanitizer Unit
Spatial interaction YES NO
Data NO NO
Material NO NO
Sanitizer Unit Waste Disposing Unit Display Unit
Spatial intrection NO NO
Data NO NO
Material NO NO