Problems and Issues Validation - A-Jayaprakash/Artisan-Marketplace GitHub Wiki
1. Problem Validation
Have you spoken to actual artisans?
-
Reach out to 2-3 artisans/NGOs (e.g., via WhatsApp or local craft communities) to validate:
-
Would they use this? What’s their biggest pain point (e.g., pricing, logistics, middlemen)?
-
Do they have smartphones/Internet access to engage with AR/blockchain?
2. Competitive Edge
Why wouldn’t artisans just use Instagram/Etsy?
Example differentiators:
-
AI Pricing: "Our algorithm guarantees you earn 2x more than Etsy’s race-to-the-bottom."
-
Zero Fees for Artisans: "First year commission-free."
3. Technical Risks
-
AR Latency: Will the experience lag on low-end phones?
-
Mitigation: Use WebXR (browser-based) instead of native apps.
-
Blockchain Costs: Gas fees for NFT provenance?
-
Mitigation: Use Polygon (low-cost) or mock a demo TXN for the hackathon.
4. Data Dependencies
-
AI Pricing Model: Where will you get localized wage data?
Hackathon Hack: Use ILO’s public datasets or mock data for 2-3 countries.
-
Artisan Stories: Who will film/edit AR content at scale?
Shortcut: Partner with One-Off NGOs (e.g., Fabindia) for pilot content.
-
User Flow Gaps How will artisans onboard?
Sketch a WhatsApp-based flow (e.g., "Send photo + voice note → we handle listings").
-
How will buyers discover products?
Plan a TikTok/Instagram hook: "Scan your rug to see if the maker was paid fairly."
6. Ethical Risks
-
Will AR exploitation happen? (e.g., buyers only watch stories but don’t purchase).
Fix: Gamify engagement (e.g., "Unlock 10 stories → get 10% off").
-
Data Colonialism: Are you extracting artisan stories without fair compensation?
Fix: Profit-sharing contracts upfront.
7. Scalability Constraints
- Can your backend handle 10K AR video scans/day?
Hackathon Answer: "We use Cloudflare Stream for cheap AR video hosting."
- How will you moderate counterfeit listings? Shortcut: "NGO partners manually verify artisans pre-launch."
8. Legal/Compliance
- What happens if AI pricing violates local laws?
Coverage: "Algorithm suggests prices, but artisans set final amounts."
-
GDPR for AR data?
Hackathon Ignore (but note for real-world: "Store only hashed artisan IDs").
9. Impact Measurement
-
How will you prove artisans earn more?
Demo Tactic: Show a before/after screenshot of an artisan’s earnings (e.g.," 3/day→8/day").
-
Pilot Test: Run a 1-day test with 1-2 real artisans (e.g., list their product on your MVP).
10. Pitch Narrative
- What’s the headline?
Weak: "A marketplace for artisans."
Strong: "Etsy exploits. We protect. Scan to pay artisans fairly."