6. PUGH CHART - A-Division-2020-2021-Odd/Repo07 GitHub Wiki

OBJECTIVES:

SL.NO. OBJECTIVES WEIGHTAGE
01 AUTOMATIC 08
02 EASY TO HANDLE 09

PUGH CHART:

OBJECTIVES WEIGHTAGE CONCEPT-1 CONCEPT-2 CONCEPT-3 CONCEPT-4
AUTOMATIC 08 ++ + 0 Datum
EASY TO HANDLE 09 - ++ - Datum
'+'SCORE 16 26 0 Datum
'-'SCORE -9 0 -9 Datum
TOTAL +5 +26 -9 0

Therefore by Pugh Chart, the best concept selected is "Concept-2".

JUSTIFICATION:

CONCEPT NO. OBJECTIVE SCORE JUSTIFICATION
1 Automatic +16 As the prototype maintain important role in automation part
Easy to handle -9 The movement of the prototype is not easy
2 Automatic +8 As it is moving in a fixed area, the instructions given can be easier through the means of any app or other means etc. So it is a best option for automatic control
Easy to handle +18 It is easy to handle as it only extends to limited space
3 Automatic 0 Arrangement is difficult hence automatic may not be good for the prototype
Easy to handle -9 The movements are quite complex, so it can't be handled so easily
4 Automatic 0 As this is a datum, the automatic in this prototype is also important through app or other means
Easy to handle 0 As this is a datum, in this prototype handling is simplified