4.Concept Generation - A-Division-2020-2021-Odd/Repo04 GitHub Wiki
Automatic stacking machine
Functions
- hold box
- lift box
- turn box
- place box
- switch on/off
- move system
- come to its original position
- sense box
- display
FUNCTION TREE

Clustering of Subsystems

Sub Systems Identified
- Gripper
- Robotic Arm
- Chessis
MORPHOLOGICAL CHART
| FUNCTIONS | OPTION1 | OPTION2 | OPTION3 | OPTION4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hold and lift the box | Mechanical picker | Fork lift | Gripper | Robotic arm |
| Turn and place box | Servo motor | lift | ||
| Switch on /off | Remote | Buttons | Plug | Auto timer |
| move system | Wheel | Roller | Track | Caterpillar track |
| Come to its original position by communicating | wifi | Bluetooth | Wire | Signals |
| Sense box | IR sensors | Ultra sonic | Laser detection | Weight sensor |
| Display | LED | Buzzer | Voice |
Picture Of Four Concepts
Design 1

Design 2

Design 3

Design 4

Design 5

CONCEPT SELECTION TEMPLATE:
Assign Weightages for stated Objectives
| Objectives | Weightage |
|---|---|
| Ease of use | 6 |
| Cost | 5 |
| quick stacking | 7 |
| precise stacking | 8 |
PUGH CHART
| Objectives | Weightage | Design idea 1 | Design idea 2 | Design idea 3 | Design idea 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| cost | 5 | ++ | DATUM | - | - |
| Easy of use | 6 | + | DATUM | + | + |
| Precise stacking | 8 | + | DATUM | + | 0 |
| quick stacking | 7 | 0 | DATUM | ++ | + |
| + Score | 24 | 28 | 13 | ||
| - Score | 0 | 5 | 5 | ||
| Total | 24 | 23 | 8 |
The best Concept selected is
Justifications:
| Design Idea no | Objective | Score given | Justification |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | precise stacking | +8 | it places the soap box systematically |
| cost | +10 | high amount tools are not required | |
| quick stacking | 0 | it takes much time to lift and stack the box | |
| Ease of use | +6 | it can easily pick and place the box | |
| 3 | precise stacking | +8 | AS the vehicle moves in one direction so there is less error of miss alligning the box |
| ease of use | +6 | as the vehcal is automatic and less intervention of human is require which makes it easy to use | |
| quick stacking | +14 | as the vehicle only moves in one direction and it does not picks the box so the time is saved between picking and changing direction of the vehicle | |
| Cost | -5 | as the number of components are more as well as the structure is larger so the cost is high | |
| 4 | ease of use | +6 | as it collects all the soap boxes by itself the human work involved is very less |
| cost | -5 | as the more number of materials is used like conveyer belt the cost is high | |
| quick stacking | +7 | after collecting the soap box it stores the boxes in the container inside it instead of placing it in another place so it saves time | |
| precise stacking | 0 | while collecting the soap box there is a chance of slippage so this machine cannot be able to stack precisely |